On April 3, 2025, ten former officials of the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) issued an open letter addressed to the legal community in response to the March 19 guidance from current EEOC Acting Chair Andrea Lucas, titled “What You Should Know About DEI-Related Discrimination at Work.” The former officials, including past commissioners, general counsels, and legal counsels, express concern that the guidance overstates legal risks and may discourage employers from pursuing lawful diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) efforts.

The letter asserts that federal law not only permits but encourages employers to take proactive steps to eliminate workplace barriers. “Under well-established legal principles,” the authors write, “employers lawfully may—and indeed should—take proactive steps to identify barriers that have limited the opportunities of applicants and employees based on any protected characteristic.” They cite relevant court decisions affirming employers’ rights to pursue diversity goals and create inclusive environments as part of their nondiscrimination obligations.

In response to the Acting Chair’s warning that DEI trainings and programs could lead to claims of a hostile work environment, the letter emphasizes that such claims are rare. It states that courts have consistently found that general discomfort with DEI topics does not meet the legal threshold for unlawful harassment. According to the authors, programs centered on respect, non-discrimination, and inclusion align with legal compliance and often support employers’ efforts to prevent workplace harassment.

The letter also addresses uncertainty around Employee Resource Groups (ERGs), affirming that voluntary, inclusive ERGs remain lawful and valuable. It explains that organizing around shared experiences is permissible under the law, provided participation is open to all employees.

The former officials conclude by outlining a positive legal framework: expanding recruitment outreach, reassessing unnecessary job qualifications, and collecting and analyzing workforce demographics to inform equal opportunity strategies. These practices, they note, remain legally permissible and central to building fair and inclusive workplaces.

The letter affirms that lawful, proactive equal employment opportunity practices remain protected under federal law and continue to serve an important role in fostering workplace fairness and compliance.